
Interactive entertainment and TV blamed for affecting young children's language ability
Video games have been blamed for helping create speech problems amongst toddlers – ahead of a possible nationwide screening programme of the problem.
Two-year-olds will reportedly be screened to tackle the problem which experts say is now more prevalent than dyslexia or autism.
According to the Telegraph:
‘Toddlers could be screened for speech problems after evidence that many are so addicted to television and video games that they are failing to learn basic communication skills.’
The decline of the traditional family meal time, the long-hours culture in the parents' workplaces, poor childcare with little stimulation and social deprivation are also being blamed.
The screening programme is being considered after a review into services for children with speech problems led by Tory MP John Bercow.
Tests could be carried out by health visitors in a similar way to that in which they check eyesight, hearing and general development.
"If children are in a home in which they are getting insufficient stimulation, where there is not enough interaction, or where communication through the spoken word is not as common or extensive or imaginative as it might be, that is bound to have an impact," Mr Bercow told the Daily Mail.
"The reality is that for far too long, speech and language problems have been under-recognised."
According to The Mail, fewer than one in ten children in disadvantaged areas know even one nursery rhyme.
In the most disturbing cases, children are not aware they have a name, let alone know what it is.
Comments
Yet again, more media controversy
I fail to see how videogames can be the main link for speech problems amongst young children when compared with television or film. When I was young and played videogames with friends we would communicate far more than if we were to sit and watch anything on television.
I would say that communication is a vital point for some of us older gamers in the current videogame trend with online gaming. If anything, the internet and texting is the main culprit in modern society.
Re: Yet again, more media controversy
Lets just be reminded that 'videogames' are the latest fad headline grabber.
And if you head over to the telegraph site the word 'videogames' only appears on the headline.
The article on the Mail website only has this to say about games:
"He (Tory MP John Bercow) called on parents to strike a balance between screen-based activities such as television and computer games and family activities, including traditional mealtimes."
I expect the next article to appear on MCV to be 'Burner dismisses Videogames as fad'
Re: Re: Yet again, more media controversy
Err, I have been playing video games as soon as my hands could hold the snes controller.
The only speech problems I have are mumbling...Which I get from my dad lol.
So yeah....No....Just no.....
Re: Re: Re: Yet again, more media controversy
Yup, because societal speech patterns never, ever change, kids aren't adopting their parents' speech patterns in the slightest.
Maybe they should be looking not just at the Toddler themselves, but at the environment they are raised in before jumping to conclusions about where to point fingers.
After all, it's a pretty dodgy investigation that announces its results before it has even taken place, can you say '"fixed"?
bad headline
While 'video games' make this an eye catching headline, it sounds like the actual problem has very, very little to do with games (esp among poor children under the age of two, who are unlikely to have the expensive hardware needed for gaming).
A better summary would have been: Busy parents and broken families lead to less in-household communication and thus less practice for young children.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Yet again, more media controversy
Well, this is just how the media is.
Whenever there's a problem with children's health, they usually blame video games.
This is unfair.
One thing that shows how ignorant this article is would be the paragraph:
"According to The Mail, fewer than one in ten children in disadvantaged areas know even one nursery rhyme."
Notice how it says, "disadvantaged areas."
The reason that they don't know a nursery rhyme, is because they're in these "disadvantaged areas."
Another thing, I remember that I played a lot of video games as a small child.
The only thing that's wrong with my voice is that it's really deep for my age.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Yet again, more media controversy
Of course we all know the idiot media are going to blow this outlandish comparison completely out of proportion.
I can just imagine the headlines......"Child plays GTA, forgets how to speak".
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Yet again, more media controversy
of course the REAL problem are memes:
'I can haz cheezburger' and other such nonsense...In fact we can stamp this out by refusing to let people keep cats and cameras.....and the internet.
Anyway, the point I was making on an earlier post is that you need to read the report before passing any judgement and typically MCV is fanning the flames, not by provoking a debate with a well inforned article, but by the chinese whispers style of reporting.
Leave a Comment
HOT TOPICS
PS3 Slim already in production? 11
Pachter: PS3 will trump 360 by 2015 11
Warner Bros boss questions pre-owned 9
‘80s home computer war becomes comedy show 9
US: Sony's PS3 titles struggle to hit 1m 9
UK console installed base tops 24m 6
Sony planned UMD-free PSP 'from the beginning' 5
Reborn Woolworths bursts into life 3
Last.FM free to XBL Gold members 3
Blu-ray sales boom in UK 2
RELATED STORIES
Mail On Sunday blasts Sony goat stunt 1
Daily Mail: Games are hurting kids 1
BYRON REVIEW: Media Reaction 4
TV ‘legend’ slams games in Daily Mail 45
Daily Mail: ‘Games are hurting kids’ 8
Daily Mail takes another potshot at games 38
Daily Mail falls in love with GTA 7
Lax games retail laws ‘damaging children’, claims MP 9
Thought-controlled gaming coming this year? 7
'Most violent Wii game ever’ slammed in Daily Mail 24
ABOUT US
MCV is the leading trade news and community site for all professionals working within the UK and international video games market. It reaches everyone from store manager to CEO, covering the entire industry. MCV is published by Intent Media, which specialises in entertainment, leisure and technology markets
















