
Finally, eBay and Amazon ban sale of illegal cards; 411,000 dodgy devices confiscated
Nintendo has revealed a major breakthrough in its fight against the pirate cards that are wrecking DS software revenues – as online giants Amazon and eBay finally agree to prohibit the sale of the devices.
The illegal cards, which include the notorious R4, allow pirates to download DS games via their PC and play them on the handheld.
MCV first drew attention to the R4 crisis in July last year, when leading publishers declared that the device was seriously hurting sales of DS software.
Independent retailers pledged to stop selling
the card as a result, but eBay and Amazon continued to allow consumers to offer the product through their respective marketplaces.
However, in a major blow to the manufacturers of the cartridges, both sites this week told MCV that they had changed their policy to support the format holder.
Advertisement
“Nintendo is pleased with the co-operation it has received from both eBay and Amazon to prevent the sales of game copying devices,” Nintendo of America’s global head of anti-piracy Jodie Daughtery told MCV this week.
“Nintendo has been aggressive in curtailing the sales of these devices on a global scale, from manufacturers in Asia to internet webshops and retail operations across Europe and the UK.
“Since January 2008, Nintendo has coordinated over 560 actions and confiscated approximately 411,000 game copiers. In the UK, Nintendo collaborates with ELSPA and takes independent actions. Over 225,000 devices have been seized by authorities in 170 actions since 2008.”
An eBay spokesperson added: “eBay prohibits sellers from listing any hardware or software that allows people to make unauthorised copies of copyrighted games, including the R4 DS cards, and we are taking steps to remove the few listings found on the site.”
And Amazon UK’s games director Chris Poad commented: “As you know, Marketplace items are sold by third parties. We have a ‘notice and take down’ process at Amazon. So where a third party believes that their IP has been infringed, they can highlight it and we can take it down. This is what happened in the case of the R4.”
MCV reported last week that display advertising for one card had appeared on social network Facebook. MCV has contacted the site for comment.
Late last year, MCV revealed that the new DSi was incompatible with R4 cards. However, since then new devices, including the R4i, have been built for use on Nintendo’s updated handheld.
Comments
too late
ok i think this is way too late now, we really dont sell many ds games, people come in to see what games are out then go and download them, any one going to ban the new card that can be used with the dsi ?? m4 card ? Nintendo ? me thinks the horse has already bolted
Illegal cards?
R4 cards aren't illegal, using them for piracy is illegal. Unless of course there has been a recent change that I am unaware of?
ebay and Amazon not selling them won't make a blind bit of difference anyway, there are still thousands of independent retailers both on and offline who are selling the cards buy the bucket load.
As the fella above said, the horse has already bolted.
Watch out...
In the next Nintendo shocker, they'll be fighting to ban the illegal PC which lets you access the internet to download the copied games. This will be closely followed by every publisher who will ban illegal blank media as it is used for pirated software of every kind.
So while Nintendo illegally blackmails users into giving up personal information in return for the full usability of their console and services, they strong-arm retailers selling what are in fact legal items... hypocrisy at its finest.
Remember, these devices DO NOT infringe the copyright any more than a blank DVD and burning software.
But of course, mention any of this and the greed driven retailers will promptly put their fingers in their ears and go La-La-Laaaaaaaaaaa.
The homebrew scene will keep these things alive, you know, those people with creative talent that this industry relies on... not the "that'll be £30 please" people, who suck the living daylights out of it.
Bit late but
Great move by Nintendo I'd say.
I guess the utter failure of GTA prompted them to get tough. And great to see Amazon and eBay get behind them.
The person above me is clearly a fool. The DS is piracy ridden because of the R4 Card and similar devices. And the fact that Nintendo is finally able to fight them is great news for the industry at large.
It could set a precedent against future devices. And hopefully future core DS owners won't be tempted by the R4 if getting hold of one will prove awkward.
lol gooood job
all they really need to crack down on is the devices that COPY the game off the card... but it is true that the R4 has no other use than storing and playing illegal copys of games so in that aspect its an illegal device... i personally hate the idea of the R4 since no game designers want to spend any money developing a game thats only going to sell 1 copy (then uploaded and downloaded by all you people that are too cheap to just buy the game) the thing thats really sad is that anybody who own's an R4 are just riding on other people's coat tails and have done nothing else but break the law and ruin things for people who actually support the DS
Eh?
Shaggy said: " R4 has no other use than storing and playing illegal copys of games"
Err, you couldn't be more wrong if you tried. Clearly the closest you've ever come to an R4 card is a picture of one.
Honestly, where do this clueless idiots come from?
The same old...
I mean, £30 for original DS games is daylight robbery. We're all aware of Nintendo's history with high prices. Pirate games will always be available for the DS. If original DS games sold for £1 each, people would still download games onto R4 cards or whatever cards are out there.
A Better Idea
Instead of removing the sale of these cards, they should just wisen up like Apple did. Downloading is going to happen...it is so much more convenient to buy 1 thing from a store and then go on your computer where you never have to leave the house to get all the data you could ever want to put on it...saves time. Instead of banning these cards...they should be smarter about it...go ahead get an R4...Nintendo should think about making their own game version of iTunes. Cost less to manufacture the game, so the price is lower and Nintendo makes a higher profit by selling games slightly discounted but no hareware costs (Nintendo blew the hardware thing with the 64 against the cost to make playstation games) and then consumers will be happy that they game have games at a much more reasonable price, and the convenience will make it much more enjoyable..apple stepped outside of the box, i think it is about time other industries did.
The device isn't illegal
Homebrew applications - essentially software created by independent developers and users - must in the same way as the creators of mods. these talents go a long way to positions in the industry.
I have an R4 "like-device" but I use my for the legal side of the fence,
I support Homebrew, Homebrew is a fantastic scene there is great applications, programs and games. I do buy retail available titles, we should not be tarred with the same brush really, but i understand nintendo feels they should take action.
Shaggy said: " R4 has no other use than storing and playing illegal copys of games"
Err, you couldn't be more wrong if you tried. Clearly the closest you've ever come to an R4 card is a picture of one.
Honestly, where do this clueless idiots come from?
Kimjohnlees agrees. just another one those who jump on the "lets clamp it down bandwagon"
Leave a Comment
HOT TOPICS
Zavvi.com in new street date row 26
Sony: PS3 will pass Xbox 360 14
Xmas release beckons for GT5 11
PSN charges in discussion 8
RETAIL BIZ: MAG takes No.1 7
PS3 sales reach 33.5m 5
Wii 2 to go beyond HD 4
Adobe in new Apple outburst 3
Yakuza 3 CE is only UK SKU 3
No standalone 250GB HDD for the UK 3
RELATED STORIES
US: ELSPA condemns piracy chip 10
Nintendo asks US to address worldwide piracy 3
JAPAN: Nintendo attacks DS piracy 9
Facebook advertises ‘new R4’ 3
DSi update cripples flash cards 12
JAPAN: Nintendo ups R4 battle
Nintendo loses Flash card lawsuit 6
Nintendo appeals Flash card case
Nintendo cracks down on piracy in Korea 1
ELSPA crackdown on R4 piracy 1
ABOUT US
MCV is the leading trade news and community site for all professionals working within the UK and international video games market. It reaches everyone from store manager to CEO, covering the entire industry. MCV is published by Intent Media, which specialises in entertainment, leisure and technology markets

















