Opinion & Analysis
RSS Feed
ACTIVISION BLIZZARD: What it all means
Michael Pachter
Analyst - Wedbush Morgan
December 3, 2007
Activision announced on Sunday that it has agreed to merge with Vivendi Games in an $18.9 billion transaction. Under the terms of the deal, Vivendi Games will be merged into Activision and Vivendi (the parent) will receive 295 million new shares of Activision common stock.
Vivendi has agreed to acquire another 24.5 million newly issued shares for up to $700 million in order to fund the tender offer, with the remaining amount of the tender to be borrowed. If the tender is fully completed, Activision Blizzard will end up with around 560 million shares, with just over two-thirds owned by Vivendi.
We estimate that the combined company will end up with around $400 million of debt, and will generate around $600 – 800 million in annual cash flow. Accordingly, we expect the company to end up with net debt of zero one year after the transaction closes, although we believe that it will be inactive on the acquisition front for another 18 months or so.
On first blush, the combined company will be a behemoth, with combined pro forma revenues of around $3.8 billion, a marketleadership position in MMOs with World of Warcraft, and with a formidable lineup of packaged products, including Guitar Hero.
Activision was well behind industry leader Electronic Arts in its development of an online gaming strategy, and the combination with Vivendi moves Activision from virtually no online presence to a market-leading presence almost overnight. The company has several franchises like Guitar Hero, Call of Duty and Tony Hawk that may be susceptible to online play, and a combination of Activision’s games prowess and Vivendi’s MMO know-how should allow the new entity to better exploit its intellectual property by selling subscriptions in Asia and the rest of the world.
We believe that World of Warcraft will continue to grow at a modest pace for several years (this contrasts with our early view that the game would peak at 4 million subscribers—it has 9.3 million at present), and we expect margins on the game to expand once the current distribution deal with The9 Ltd. expires in 2009. We have much work to do to be in a position to explain the structure of the current deal, but our understanding is that Blizzard has opened up Asian distribution of WOW to competitive bid, and any renewal of the deal should be at substantially higher margins in 2010 and beyond.
Accordingly, we think that the price “paid” for Vivendi Games (approximately 15x operating income) may end up being a bargain.
Activision expects the transaction to close in the first half of calendar 2008, and expects the deal to be immediately accretive to its shareholders. The transaction has been approved by both the Activision and Vivendi boards, and must be approved by Activision shareholders and by Federal and EU regulators. The company estimates that the combination will generate pro forma EPS in excess of $1.20 in calendar 2009.
We believe that Activision was on pace to generate around the same amount on its own, but note that the company currently has around 320 million outstanding shares, implying $384 million in net income, while the new company will have around 560 million shares, implying around $672 million in net income.
The new company will be called Activision Blizzard, and key Activision management will retain leadership roles. Activision CEO Bobby Kotick will remain CEO, COO Mike Griffith will remain CEO of the Publishing group, and CFO Thomas Tippl will remain CFO of the combined entity. Vivendi CEO Bruce Hack will become Chief Corporate Officer and Mike Morhaime will remain CEO of Blizzard. Jean-Francois Grollemund will transition from Vivendi CFO to Chief Accounting Officer of Activision Blizzard. Vivendi will control six of the 11 board positions, and current Activision Co-Chairman Brian Kelly will become Co-Chairman of Activision Blizzard.
We believe that the transaction should be viewed by investors as a merger of equals, with Activision operating management remaining in control of the combined entity, subject to oversight by the Vivendi board. We are generally positive on the combination, as we think it strengthens Activision’s product offering and expands its geographic reach, while allowing Vivendi to further monetize its success with World of Warcraft.
It is difficult to assess the potential growth of WOW, but we believe that Vivendi’s presence in Asia and market leading position in MMOs provides Activision with the potential to expand many of its games to online play.
Raising our price target to $30 from $27.50, but lowering our rating to BUY from STRONG BUY, primarily due to the limited upside from Monday’s likely closing price. We have little visibility into the earnings power of the combined company, and must accept management guidance.
Accordingly, we think it is reasonable to assume that Activision Blizzard will earn $1.20 in calendar 2009, and that its shares will be valued based upon a forward multiple applied to that figure. Our price target values Activision Blizzard at 25x calendar 2009 EPS, at the low end of its historical multiple range due to the lack of near-term visibility.
Michael Pachter is a leading games analyst for Wedbush Morgan
Recent Columns
- COMMENT: Something like a phenomenon
May 16 - Neil Long
- Will EA buy Take Two this week?
May 13 - Michael Pachter
- COMMENT: PS3 slips into top gear
May 9 - Neil Long
- How the music industry got it wrong: Pt 2
May 8 - Nicholas Lovell
- How the music industry got it wrong: Pt 1
May 8 - Nicholas Lovell
- COMMENT: Believe the hype
May 2 - Neil Long
- 'Music in games is the new rock and roll'
April 29 - Tahir Basheer
- COMMENT: Relax, don't do it
April 25 - Lisa Foster
- COMMENT: Are we normal?
April 18 - Neil Long
- Cinemas - a brave new world for gaming?
April 17 - Mark De Quervain
- The Industry vs. Tanya Byron: Pt 3/3
April 15 - Ray Maguire
- COMMENT - MCV Awards
April 11 - Stuart Dinsey
- The Industry vs. Dr Tanya Byron: Pt. 2/3
April 9 - Paul Jackson
- The Industry vs. Dr Tanya Byron: Pt. 1/3
April 8 - David Reeves
- Isn't it Byronic?
April 2 - Professor Mark Griffiths
- "Get behind Play.com Live"
April 1 - Jonathan Weinberg
- "Gibson relishes a good court case"
April 1 - Andy Barrett
- "Ken Kutaragi was my biggest inspiration"
March 28 - Chris Deering
- This Tanya Byron Lunacy
March 27 - Bruce Everiss
- Take Two has made a mistake
March 26 - Michael Pachter
- ANALYST REACTION: EA’s bid gets hostile
March 20 - The industry's leading analysts
- COMMENT - Can EA be a true Rockstar?
March 20 - Neil Long
- GameStop financial analysis
March 18 - Richard Fontaine
- COMMENT: Convergence is back
March 14 - Neil Long
- Take Two financials - analysis
March 12 - Michael Pachter
- QUICKFIRE Q&A: GAME
March 10 - Lisa Morgan
- All hail the MCV Awards finalists
March 6 - Stuart Dinsey
- RETAILER PROFILE - DSGi
March 5 - David Johnson
- EA & Take Two - the analyst view
March 3 - Colin Sebastian, Nick Parker, Piers Harding-Rolls, Michael Pachter, Edward Williams & Thomas Andrews
- Phil Harrison - Fanfare for the common man
February 29 - Stuart Dinsey
- ‘Don’t ditch PEGI ratings’
February 28 - Patrice Chazerand
- Why Take Two must accept EA's offer
February 26 - Michael Pachter
- Why we want Take Two
February 25 - John Riccitiello
- The trend that won't go away
February 22 - Neil Long
- What now for SCI?
February 21 - Nicholas Lovell
- WoW hits 10 million
February 19 - J Allen Brack
- Never a dull moment in Gardner's world
February 15 - Neil Long
- 'The British Goverment is stupid'
February 13 - Bruce Everiss
- Games ratings: Have we all calmed down now?
February 11 - Christopher Dring
- Tabloid aggression would be Prime evil
February 7 - Tim Ingham
- How GAME can keep it up
February 4 - James Flower
- Yet more shock and awe
January 31 - Neil Long
- The games of 2007: Analysis
January 30 - Andrew Wooden
- This year will struggle to beat ‘07
January 29 - Rick Porter
- Games aren’t crack, stupid; they’re games
January 25 - Neil Long
- Introducing the MCV Awards '08...
January 24 - Stuart Dinsey
- Zavvi New Year
January 23 - Simon Douglas
- What went wrong at SCi
January 22 - Nicholas Lovell
- Warner and SCi: Another twist in the tale
January 18 - David Cole
- COMMENT: Seriously, Happy New year
January 11 - Neil Long
- Retail review: Christmas trading
January 9 - René Wright
- Say What?
January 3 - Quotes of the year
- All hail the three kings - Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo
December 20 - Martyn Gibbs
- The Manhunt 2 saga just keeps on going...
December 18 - Neil Long
- Xbox and Nintendo clean up in the MCV Retail Survey
December 14 - Neil Long
- Q4 PLATFORM BATTLE PART 4: PC
December 13 - Russell Barnes
- Q4 PLATFORM BATTLE PART 3: PS3
December 12 - Henning Hoffman
- Q4 PLATFORM BATTLE PART 2: Nintendo
December 11 - Mark Green
- Q4 PLATFORM BATTLE PART 1: Xbox 360
December 10 - Jon Hicks
- ACTIVISION BLIZZARD: Wake up Hollywood
December 7 - Stuart Dinsey
- 2007 – a proper gaming vintage
December 4 - Ben Parfitt
- There’s no escaping the festive frenzy
November 30 - Neil Long
- The digital download BBFC loophole
November 28 - Phil Lee & Ray Coyle
- Gender differences in gaming
November 27 - Professor Mark Griffiths
- Play.com Live - Ready to Play the field
November 26 - Tim Ingham
- The need for new IP
November 23 - Neil Long
- Developers should develop themselves
November 21 - Simon Jones
- Sex in games
November 20 - Bruce Everiss
- Quality key to effective advertising
November 16 - Dan Coleman
- COMMENT: Play-ing with the big boys
November 15 - Tim Ingham
- Why do films get tax breaks and we don’t?
November 13 - Mick Morris
- Capcom's Western mission statement
November 12 - Michael Pattison
- The annual Q4 stock headache
November 9 - Neil Long
- Italian Territory Report
November 7 - Valentina Frigerio
- Getting ready for the Q4 rush
November 6 - Neil Long
- When Hodge met ELSPA
November 5 - Margaret Hodge
- Lest we forget: The Power of PS2
November 2 - Neil Long
- Braben on pre-owned software
November 1 - David Braben
- Publishers need to trust developers
October 30 - Jason Kingsley
- Games can help people learn
October 29 - Professor Stephen Heppell
- A trade body with teeth... Yes, really
October 24 - Stuart Dinsey
- Violence in video games and its effect on children
October 22 - Amanda Gummer
- Our very own media darlings
October 19 - Neil Long
- Mobile gaming is maturing fast
October 18 - Bernard Dugdale
- How to get girls gaming
October 16 - Jane Cunningham
- It’s Prime time for Brown to listen to you
October 12 - Tim Ingham
- Publishers: Know your rights
October 10 - Alex Chapman
- Give us gamers more titles like Halo
October 8 - Ben Parfitt
- Games Industry Status - Hooked on Facebook
October 4 - Lisa Foster
- GMAs: Media Frenzy
October 2 - Dave Roberts
- Gamestation's staff are key for Christmas
October 1 - Martyn Gibbs
- Next-gen analysis
September 28 - Nick Parker
- Niche work if you can get it
September 25 - Dermot Stapledon
- COMMENT - Warner warms up
September 21 - Stuart Dinsey
- COMMENT - No Longer Virgins
September 21 - Andrew Wooden
- Let’s get gamers off their arses
September 19 - Simon Lovell
- We shouldn't cheapen games degrees
September 18 - Matthew Jeffery
- Leipzig 1 London 0
September 14 - Stuart Dinsey
- GC must move to fulfil its potential
September 13 - Steve Boxer
- Why we dropped the 360’s price
September 11 - Dan Cornelius
- COMMENT: Hitman and her
September 7 - Lisa Foster
- LEIPZIG REVIEW: Sony steals the show
September 4 - Neil Long
- COMMENT: Cameron’s attack is worse news for him than us
August 31 - Tim Ingham
- The new Hollywood?
August 28 - Matthew Jeffery
- COMMENT: Warner toons into games
August 24 - Neil Long
- ANALYSIS: Territory report: Germany
August 20 - IDG
- COMMENT: Retail’s love triangle
August 17 - Neil Long
- Virtual worlds, real research
August 15 - Professor Mark Griffiths
- Eidos’ real heroine
August 14 - Jane Cavanagh
- Sega on Q4 '07
August 13 - Mike Hayes
- COMMENT: Every Cloud...
August 9 - Neil Long
- Better graphics mean better gameplay
August 9 - Phil Wright
- The problem with games retail
August 7 - Richard Hammond
- Toy firms to roll the dice again?
August 2 - Lisa Foster
- ‘We know what we must do’
July 27 - Phil Harrison
- Tesco turns supplier
July 26 - Neil Long
- Warranty move will generate more consumer confidence
July 23 - Chris Lewis
- Vegas or New York? A less elitist E3 beckons
July 20 - Stuart Dinsey
- Rivalling the online super-powers
July 18 - Matt Holland
- Kids today
July 17 - Michael Wolstenholme
- A brand new 'Vision for the future
July 16 - Andrew Brown
- E3 without me
July 12 - Lisa Foster
- E3: Postcards From The E3dge
July 11 - Simon Byron
- ‘We’re disrupting the games world with Kidman ads’
July 10 - Dawn Paine
- Let’s rally Government for a level playing field
July 9 - Ian Livingstone
- UK parliament must sit up and take notice
July 6 - Neil Long
- Was the BBFC right to ban Manhunt 2?
June 29 - Roger Bennett
- Casual games are getting serious
June 28 - Neil Long
- More demo events mean more sales
June 27 - Stephen Lynn
- How to make interactivity mainstream
June 25 - Chris Deering
- ELSPA the defender - unless you're Rockstar
June 22 - Stuart Dinsey
- The childrens’ gaming market
June 20 - Michael Wolstenholme
- What women want
June 18 - Patrick O’Luanaigh
- Take 2 Part 2
June 15 - Lisa Foster
- The PS3 powers on
June 8 - David Reeves
- Community key to Pro Evo
June 4 - Jon Murphy
- Mainstream audience is key for Football Manager online
June 4 - Miles Jacobson
- Brown but not out
June 1 - Stuart Dinsey
- Real PS3 numbers, modestly revealed
June 1 - Lisa Foster
- European studios are vital to 360’s future success
May 30 - Phil Spencer
- PC is not just a cash cow
May 30 - Darryl Still
- ‘God bless the games industry’
May 29 - Iain Lee
- We give indies the chance to shine online
May 2 - Chris Ratcliff
- Warcraft is taking over the world
May 2 - Ross Atherton
- Thinking outside the Xbox
May 2 - Stephen McGill
- The biggest change is yet to come
May 2 - Tim Smith
- Talk of trade shows must be constructive
May 2 - Simon Harvey
- Quality will never go out of fashion
May 2 - Jonathan Weinberg
- Print media must move quicker
May 2 - Steve Boxer
- Only Elite gamers will buy new 360
May 2 - Stu Taylor
- Nintendo is on the right track with Sonic
May 2 - Paul Davies
- Bored of the ABCs
May 2 - Gary Cutlack
- No-one’s above our ‘Station
April 7 - David Wilson










